SPEED MODELING CHALLENGE No. 45 (Lamppost) - WINNERS

[Raider]

THE WINNER - amin2001




AWARD:
Speed Modeling Award (T) - for the best modeling



===============================================

THE WINNER - e-Design



AWARD:
Speed Modeling Award (C) - for the best concept



===============================================

All Challengers are here: SPEED MODELING CHALLENGE No. 45 (Lamppost)
See you all the next challenge that will start today later.

[Need_Help]

Congratulations

[amin2001]

this topic was the best , every one has amazing Posts
i didnt expect wining cuz they were amazing works beside mine,even better than mine,there is only one judge which is R@IDER and i respect his choose even if it wasnt me
Thnx R@IDER For Choosing me

COngrats to E-Design
i HOPE TO seee you All in the next Topic


THnx Need_Help

[buddy32]

If these are the real winners, why amin's the traditional, and why e-design the concept?

[buddy32]

I thought that the concept model is a new concept that isn't exist, just a new imagine!

[behrang]

you got the right choise R@IDER
congrats to the winners

[Raider]

If these are the real winners, why amin's the traditional, and why e-design the concept

I think for a long time about winners and decide that Amin's work the best in such parameters as: idea and it realization. I don't see better traditional realization than in Amin concept work and I can't give 2 awards to Amin and think that the main speed modelling award is the better award for his work.
Also in challenge topic I see that many guys like Amin work and I think that they are also agree that Amin's work is the best.

For future it will be nice to post opinions about works that you like in challenge topic.
Thanks for all!
RaideR

[minimus]

congratulation to the winners.

i agree. why is amin the best modeling, it would fitt better under best consept, alsow becaus e-Design has better detail and more modeling behind it.
but anyway. good pick Raider:)

[amin2001]

Thnx R@IDER

Thnx minimus

[behrang]

buddy you will win next round

[setheo]

hi

in the last weeks i've watched the works of the artists posting pictures for the contests - in the first time the main reason i've come here is to 'realize' that 3d modelling is not easy, and because i wanted to get bit closer to these things, without actually doing it, and learn how to appreciate people's modells in the right way
but today i've come to a point that i don't really understand, you give away prizes for the winners - and that's a really good thing, but i'm a bit confused today when i've saw that amin won the last contest.. (sorry amin, but you don't touched my heart ;) ..
i don't have expert knowledge in any modelling environment, and i'm not an expert in 3d graphics - but i do know that how things work in the backgrounds -- simply put: i'm a programmer

so i look at the images, and i want to be as objective as possible, i search for small errors(edges etc), i'm tring to catch the good things in the image, and i try to push the object into a natural/artifical environment where it can fit ( you can have a good model - but if it don't fits anywhere, just in mary poopin's world - i think it's clear enough )

i've thinked till now that the results are selected by professional members, and are based on observations like my pro/con analysis.
in the last times i've reached a point to agree with the competition's committe on the result - till today..
e-design's work is fine, it can decorate a larger park nicely - with it's nice early xx. century look
but..(i know that this is speed modelling, and to don't expect much)...but amin's work is a good example which don't fit in any environment - and it doesn't have any architectural design - it's a big clothesline (if i wan't to be precise) with a burning hearth in the middle. and the worst in all of this, that it's looks so harmless, fragile, not something that can hold the line against the force of nature, especially the gravity, which would tear out the heart first time the building scaffolds are removed.

no offense amin - try to catch the real meaning all of this and don't hang me on the south gate ;)

setheo

[fantk]

i agree with u setheo..... i'm sorry....... but it's not even a lamppost

[amin2001]

Guysss
i didnt Choose my Self !!!!!! Did i ?
i have just done my best modeling and the best concept i found
the judge is R@IDER and STRYker , ask them about this
my idea was to have a strange background
like a love world or smth
so this could fit there as a lamppost !!
it cant fit in the real world for sure
but if a wanted to make all those strange things and stuffs , so that you could have understand my lamppost it would take more than 5 Hr work !!!!
so i just done the lamppost , i thought you will understand my idea by your own , but u did not

i think i will fit better under concept award R@IDER
is better if you change the winner place
so there will be no more problems about this

Thnx

[amin2001]

But i dont know why didnt you guys tell me this isnt a lamppost in the challenge page !!!!