SPEED MODELING CHALLENGE No. 139 (Electric Guitar) - WINNERS

[Stryker]

THE WINNER - SublimeStudio



AWARD:
Speed Modeling Award (T) - for the best modeling



===============================================

THE WINNER - drawknezz



AWARD:
Speed Modeling Award (C) - for the best concept



See you all the next challenge that will start today later.

[micha224]

gratz to the winners

[SublimeStudio]

Originally Posted by micha224

gratz to the winners

Thank you .although this was this was very unexpected for me,i am very happy.looking forward for the next challenges

[fireboymatt]

"This is my 1st entry ever on this website,i hope i do it right.

Modelling: 4 hours
Software: 3Dstudio Max 2010
Texturing: 50 min
Rendering: 10 min"

Thats wrong, he wasn't within the time limit. It was 2 hours and he took 4. Sory for being pedantic but the rules are the rules? amirite?

[SublimeStudio]

Originally Posted by fireboymatt

"This is my 1st entry ever on this website,i hope i do it right.

Modelling: 4 hours
Software: 3Dstudio Max 2010
Texturing: 50 min
Rendering: 10 min"

Thats wrong, he wasn't within the time limit. It was 2 hours and he took 4. Sory for being pedantic but the rules are the rules? amirite?

as i said this is my 1st entry,i didnt even notice the 2 hours limit.but from what i can tell the other entries have broken the rules in one way or another.if i were to write 2 hours it couldn't be verified,that goes for the other entries as well.just saying

[shashanks18]

brilliant work guys!!! congrats to both

@Fireboymatt......mate, if u have to make details in an electric guitar...it can really take very long indeed.. :)

[Micheus]

Originally Posted by fireboymatt

Thats wrong, he wasn't within the time limit. It was 2 hours and he took 4. Sory for being pedantic but the rules are the rules? amirite?

I'm in accord with you. It's not fair with the others .

slickX already alert about it in a post before Striker has announced the winner and when i received the notification, i did send a mail to Striker (no response) talking about this.

Originally Posted by shashanks18

@Fireboymatt......mate, if u have to make details in an electric guitar...it can really take very long indeed.. :)

Of course it's a excellent work, but the rules should be clear and i'm sure that other excellent works would be here if the time were greater.

Originally Posted by SublimeStudio

...i didnt even notice the 2 hours limit.

If you did read the first post at the thread you must have noticed that all information is there. Including time limit.

[SublimeStudio]

"-Your model must include a clear and easy to see wire frame of the mesh before any smoothing or subdivision has been applied. Please use a screen grab. No other method is acceptable and any "wire renders" or wireframes we can't see properly will be removed and the poster disqualified. "

if you really want to follow the rules word by word it's fine by me,but 3 other submissions including drawknezz's winning submission would be disqualified for submittind either screens with smoothing or subdivisions on them,or the screen grab.i feel i'm being targeted here,and it's not exactly friendly

[shashanks18]

Originally Posted by Micheus

Of course it's a excellent work, but the rules should be clear and i'm sure that other excellent works would be here if the time were greater.

:) hv to agree with that too on the other hand

well probably the judge might have missed his given time? or maybe he found this as the best(not taunting others....gr8 entries all!!)...

anyways, i guess we shud leave this be right nw, but ask the judges to be a li'l stricter from the next time.

Cheers!!!

[fireboymatt]

I wasn't having a go at anyone and i know most people dont submit the right kind of wire images but the time limit is kind of the one major rule i would say.
The whole point of the competition is to model something in a time limit. Hence it is called speed modeling.
Didn't want to upset anyone.

[slickX]

Dude just drop it.He won! Congratz!! next time ill make 2 models one in the given time and other within double the time just for fun. It should be about having fun and as much entries as possible.
Waiting for next challenge.Guys be prepared and good luck to all.I was a little upset at first and then i taught why be? SublimeStudio enjoy the winning and hope to see you on the next one.Peace

[fireboymatt]

Alright, calm your beans.

[Kec]

I agree with fireboymatt ... it is ok to post bad wireframe but the point of this challenge is to model somtheing in time that is written ... that is a great model but it took him 4 hours to complete... it is just unfair to us who are trying to do model in time